Expert runtime: Common Lisp Tek9 store + typed Prolog shim

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 12:49:11 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Parent: #8

Goal

Build the reusable expert/runtime substrate before implementing individual experts.

Canonical ownership

Current authority is research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-033-expert-authority-regression-reconciliation.org; active implementation is PR #24 on rage/10-expert-runtime-red.

Python llm-log capture/transport
  -> immutable raw evidence
  -> versioned typed expert protocol
  -> Common Lisp expert runtime
  -> bounded Tek9 projection/retrieval
  -> supervised persistent SWI-Prolog
  -> validated typed derived result

Python remains capture/transport: transparent HTTP/SSE/WebSocket forwarding, provider/upstream compatibility, immutable capture/redaction, and expert availability policy.
Common Lisp owns the expert runtime: Tek9 access, typed objects/contracts, bounded fact materialization, SWI-Prolog supervision, result validation, and durable derived assertions.
Tek9 is the canonical durable document/graph KB.
SWI-Prolog owns facts/rules/inference.
Do not implement a second Python rule engine or a Common Lisp transport rewrite.
Historical zero-Python language from #20 and older issue text is superseded.

Typed protocol

Keep the transport-to-expert boundary versioned and typed. Declared operations include at least:

observe_user_message
observe_request
observe_response
observe_usage
query_classification
query_task
query_outcome
query_rewrite
health

Only declared operations + typed data are legal. No arbitrary call_prolog, goal strings, callable terms, term_string/2, read_term/3, or equivalent escape hatch.

Common Lisp lifecycle

start/open expert runtime;
keep one Tek9 environment open for host lifetime;
supervise one persistent SWI-Prolog worker/session;
ingest observations idempotently;
execute named expert queries;
enforce timeout/result-count/term-shape bounds;
validate operation-specific results;
persist derived assertions with source IDs + rule/version + expert version;
recover on later requests after reasoner failure without implicit replay of ambiguous in-flight inference;
clean shutdown.

Do not spawn SWI-Prolog per query.

Tek9 projection

Persist typed records with stable IDs for observations, tasks, assertions, evidence, rules/rule versions, usage and immutable pricing snapshots. Use bounded indexed lookups; never materialize the whole corpus into Prolog.

Event ingestion is idempotent by stable event ID. Identical replay must not duplicate data; contradictory replay returns explicit conflict and must not overwrite immutable evidence. Historical derived revisions are superseded, never deleted.

Use graph edges where useful for provenance: task -> request, assertion -> evidence, rewrite -> source message, child-task -> parent-task.

Use existing Tek9 public APIs first. Modify Tek9 only if a proven missing generic primitive blocks this substrate.

Prolog shim

Common Lisp must:

fetch only bounded indexed relevant Tek9 records;
translate them into declared typed facts;
invoke only declared expert predicates;
enforce timeout/result-count/term-shape limits;
validate returned terms against operation-specific expectations;
persist derived assertions with exact source/rule/expert provenance;
return typed results carrying expert/rule/KB/evidence provenance.

Untrusted/model-controlled strings remain data and never become executable Prolog source.

Failure semantics

expert unavailable: forwarding remains fail-open by default;
explicit require_expert_plane: fail closed;
expert/query failures are typed failures, never empty-success;
reasoner crash/timeout/malformed result invalidates the worker and does not automatically replay ambiguous inference;
capture/redaction failure must never cause credentials to be persisted;
classification metadata never grants authority;
transport 200 never implies task success.

Nix / non-Nix

Keep the existing flake. Package the expert service reproducibly with SBCL, Tek9 and SWI-Prolog. Expose Home Manager/systemd configuration while preserving a normal standalone launch/config path. Reusable mutable state defaults under ~/.llm-proxy, expert state under ~/.llm-proxy/expert, and consumer dotfiles may keep raw capture at ~/Documents/AI/proxy. Credentials must not enter the Nix store.

RED-first acceptance

Before every production mutation, execute the smallest legitimate failing contract against the untouched pre-implementation head and record exact SHA/command/failure. Existing executed branch evidence covers the Tek9/SWI substrate, assertion provenance/supersession, reasoner recovery, Python availability policy, concrete Python->CL adapter, HTTP/WebSocket lifecycle, CLI expert launch, and Home Manager expert wiring.

No unavailable test result may be presented as evidence.

Current dependency order

#10 remains the first substrate. #12, #13, #15 and #17 remain blocked behind it. Provider census #6 remains backlog and must not displace the expert-plane priority. Dotfiles PR #172 remains RED-only until an eligible reviewed + exact-head GREEN #24 revision exists.

Merge gate

Merge only an exact current head that is GREEN, mergeable, and satisfies required reviews/discussions. PR #5 remains a separate configuration transaction and must not be polluted by #10.

Parent: #8 ## Goal Build the reusable expert/runtime substrate before implementing individual experts. ## Canonical ownership Current authority is `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-033-expert-authority-regression-reconciliation.org`; active implementation is PR #24 on `rage/10-expert-runtime-red`. ```text Python llm-log capture/transport -> immutable raw evidence -> versioned typed expert protocol -> Common Lisp expert runtime -> bounded Tek9 projection/retrieval -> supervised persistent SWI-Prolog -> validated typed derived result ``` - **Python remains capture/transport:** transparent HTTP/SSE/WebSocket forwarding, provider/upstream compatibility, immutable capture/redaction, and expert availability policy. - **Common Lisp owns the expert runtime:** Tek9 access, typed objects/contracts, bounded fact materialization, SWI-Prolog supervision, result validation, and durable derived assertions. - **Tek9** is the canonical durable document/graph KB. - **SWI-Prolog** owns facts/rules/inference. - Do not implement a second Python rule engine or a Common Lisp transport rewrite. - Historical zero-Python language from #20 and older issue text is superseded. ## Typed protocol Keep the transport-to-expert boundary versioned and typed. Declared operations include at least: - `observe_user_message` - `observe_request` - `observe_response` - `observe_usage` - `query_classification` - `query_task` - `query_outcome` - `query_rewrite` - `health` Only declared operations + typed data are legal. No arbitrary `call_prolog`, goal strings, callable terms, `term_string/2`, `read_term/3`, or equivalent escape hatch. ## Common Lisp lifecycle - start/open expert runtime; - keep one Tek9 environment open for host lifetime; - supervise one persistent SWI-Prolog worker/session; - ingest observations idempotently; - execute named expert queries; - enforce timeout/result-count/term-shape bounds; - validate operation-specific results; - persist derived assertions with source IDs + rule/version + expert version; - recover on later requests after reasoner failure without implicit replay of ambiguous in-flight inference; - clean shutdown. Do not spawn SWI-Prolog per query. ## Tek9 projection Persist typed records with stable IDs for observations, tasks, assertions, evidence, rules/rule versions, usage and immutable pricing snapshots. Use bounded indexed lookups; never materialize the whole corpus into Prolog. Event ingestion is idempotent by stable event ID. Identical replay must not duplicate data; contradictory replay returns explicit conflict and must not overwrite immutable evidence. Historical derived revisions are superseded, never deleted. Use graph edges where useful for provenance: task -> request, assertion -> evidence, rewrite -> source message, child-task -> parent-task. Use existing Tek9 public APIs first. Modify Tek9 only if a proven missing generic primitive blocks this substrate. ## Prolog shim Common Lisp must: 1. fetch only bounded indexed relevant Tek9 records; 2. translate them into declared typed facts; 3. invoke only declared expert predicates; 4. enforce timeout/result-count/term-shape limits; 5. validate returned terms against operation-specific expectations; 6. persist derived assertions with exact source/rule/expert provenance; 7. return typed results carrying expert/rule/KB/evidence provenance. Untrusted/model-controlled strings remain data and never become executable Prolog source. ## Failure semantics - expert unavailable: forwarding remains fail-open by default; - explicit `require_expert_plane`: fail closed; - expert/query failures are typed failures, never empty-success; - reasoner crash/timeout/malformed result invalidates the worker and does not automatically replay ambiguous inference; - capture/redaction failure must never cause credentials to be persisted; - classification metadata never grants authority; - transport 200 never implies task success. ## Nix / non-Nix Keep the existing flake. Package the expert service reproducibly with SBCL, Tek9 and SWI-Prolog. Expose Home Manager/systemd configuration while preserving a normal standalone launch/config path. Reusable mutable state defaults under `~/.llm-proxy`, expert state under `~/.llm-proxy/expert`, and consumer dotfiles may keep raw capture at `~/Documents/AI/proxy`. Credentials must not enter the Nix store. ## RED-first acceptance Before every production mutation, execute the smallest legitimate failing contract against the untouched pre-implementation head and record exact SHA/command/failure. Existing executed branch evidence covers the Tek9/SWI substrate, assertion provenance/supersession, reasoner recovery, Python availability policy, concrete Python->CL adapter, HTTP/WebSocket lifecycle, CLI expert launch, and Home Manager expert wiring. No unavailable test result may be presented as evidence. ## Current dependency order #10 remains the first substrate. #12, #13, #15 and #17 remain blocked behind it. Provider census #6 remains backlog and must not displace the expert-plane priority. Dotfiles PR #172 remains RED-only until an eligible reviewed + exact-head GREEN #24 revision exists. ## Merge gate Merge only an exact current head that is GREEN, mergeable, and satisfies required reviews/discussions. PR #5 remains a separate configuration transaction and must not be polluted by #10.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 13:12:31 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Dependency/progress reconciliation for the active Auto-RAGE transaction:

Active implementation remains draft PR #18; do not create a second branch.
Typed Python expert protocol contract is implemented and locally reproduced 6/6 green on Python 3.13.
Common Lisp llm-log-expert ASDF/package skeleton now exists with a reusable Tek9 host lifecycle seam.
Upstream Nix consumption gap is tracked at lost-rob0t/tek9#7; Tek9 currently exposes an x86_64 dev shell but no downstream-consumable package output.
The integration gate remains RED until a real environment executes the black-box CL/Tek9/SWI contract.

Next bounded realization: persistent supervised SWI-Prolog session + closed named-operation JSON-lines dispatcher, followed by executable/Nix packaging and idempotent Tek9 projection.

Dependency/progress reconciliation for the active Auto-RAGE transaction: - Active implementation remains draft PR #18; do not create a second branch. - Typed Python expert protocol contract is implemented and locally reproduced **6/6 green** on Python 3.13. - Common Lisp `llm-log-expert` ASDF/package skeleton now exists with a reusable Tek9 host lifecycle seam. - Upstream Nix consumption gap is tracked at `lost-rob0t/tek9#7`; Tek9 currently exposes an x86_64 dev shell but no downstream-consumable package output. - The integration gate remains RED until a real environment executes the black-box CL/Tek9/SWI contract. Next bounded realization: persistent supervised SWI-Prolog session + closed named-operation JSON-lines dispatcher, followed by executable/Nix packaging and idempotent Tek9 projection.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 16:19:53 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE cycle update:

Reusable mutable state is ~/.llm-proxy; expert default is ~/.llm-proxy/expert. Personal corpus paths are consumer overrides, not llm-log defaults.
Tek9 packaging blocker is resolved on merged Tek9 master; this slice required no new Tek9 primitive because existing composable with-write-transaction supports atomic event projection + KB-revision mutation.
RED-first contract hardening landed at 37d2f8d1: contradictory replay must return event_conflict without overwriting evidence, and revision/idempotency must survive service restart.
The active PR #18 now contains the CL-owned persistent SWI worker, transactional event:<id> projection, durable meta:kb-revision, closed service dispatcher, fixture event_transport path, packaged llm-log-expert executable, and a Nix expert-service-contract check.
Canonical transaction evidence is persisted in research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-007-expert-service-transaction.org.

Truthful gate: no SBCL/SWI-Prolog/Nix execution is available in the current environment, so no GREEN is claimed. Keep #12/#13/#15/#17 blocked and keep PR #18 draft until the packaged black-box contract executes GREEN on its exact head.

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE cycle update: - Reusable mutable state is `~/.llm-proxy`; expert default is `~/.llm-proxy/expert`. Personal corpus paths are consumer overrides, not llm-log defaults. - Tek9 packaging blocker is resolved on merged Tek9 `master`; this slice required no new Tek9 primitive because existing composable `with-write-transaction` supports atomic event projection + KB-revision mutation. - RED-first contract hardening landed at `37d2f8d1`: contradictory replay must return `event_conflict` without overwriting evidence, and revision/idempotency must survive service restart. - The active PR #18 now contains the CL-owned persistent SWI worker, transactional `event:<id>` projection, durable `meta:kb-revision`, closed service dispatcher, fixture `event_transport` path, packaged `llm-log-expert` executable, and a Nix `expert-service-contract` check. - Canonical transaction evidence is persisted in `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-007-expert-service-transaction.org`. Truthful gate: no SBCL/SWI-Prolog/Nix execution is available in the current environment, so no GREEN is claimed. Keep #12/#13/#15/#17 blocked and keep PR #18 draft until the packaged black-box contract executes GREEN on its exact head.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 17:12:28 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Storage-contract reconciliation for #10: the reusable mutable-state default is ~/.llm-proxy, with expert state at ~/.llm-proxy/expert/. Standalone configuration/CLI and Home Manager may override it; consumer dotfiles may explicitly select ~/Documents/AI/proxy. Older issue prose mentioning $XDG_DATA_HOME/llm-log/expert/ as the default is superseded by the canonical configuration decision and active expert-plane Org documents. See research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-008-reasoner-crash-recovery.org on rage/10-expert-runtime-red.

Storage-contract reconciliation for #10: the reusable mutable-state default is `~/.llm-proxy`, with expert state at `~/.llm-proxy/expert/`. Standalone configuration/CLI and Home Manager may override it; consumer dotfiles may explicitly select `~/Documents/AI/proxy`. Older issue prose mentioning `$XDG_DATA_HOME/llm-log/expert/` as the default is superseded by the canonical configuration decision and active expert-plane Org documents. See `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-008-reasoner-crash-recovery.org` on `rage/10-expert-runtime-red`.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 19:15:08 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Auto-ARADR/RAGE #10 update (bounded result-validation slice):

canonical design added: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-010-reasoner-result-validation.org (741a1b9c)
RED fixture/contract: fdd22298 + f63fa1a4 prove a correctly correlated status=ok SWI reply can still be unsafe if its operation-specific result is forged/malformed
CL implementation: 0ddbbe78 validates event_transport result object/type, exact agreement with the bounded Tek9 fact, and non-empty rule provenance; contract violation invalidates the worker without mutating Tek9/KB revision
public typed failure: addd9e37 returns invalid_reasoner_result
packaged gate: a7999f86 adds the new contract to checks.<system>.expert-service-contract

No Tek9 API change was needed. No Python rule engine was added. No GREEN execution is claimed: exact head still has no reported GitHub status checks and the packaged SBCL/SWI/Nix contract has not been executed in this environment.

Storage correction remains authoritative: reusable state defaults to ~/.llm-proxy, expert state to ~/.llm-proxy/expert, with explicit config/CLI/Home Manager override. The older XDG-default wording in the issue body is stale; canonical Org/PR design uses the corrected contract. Dotfiles continues to override the consumer corpus to ~/Documents/AI/proxy.

Auto-ARADR/RAGE #10 update (bounded result-validation slice): - canonical design added: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-010-reasoner-result-validation.org` (`741a1b9c`) - RED fixture/contract: `fdd22298` + `f63fa1a4` prove a correctly correlated `status=ok` SWI reply can still be unsafe if its operation-specific result is forged/malformed - CL implementation: `0ddbbe78` validates `event_transport` result object/type, exact agreement with the bounded Tek9 fact, and non-empty rule provenance; contract violation invalidates the worker without mutating Tek9/KB revision - public typed failure: `addd9e37` returns `invalid_reasoner_result` - packaged gate: `a7999f86` adds the new contract to `checks.<system>.expert-service-contract` No Tek9 API change was needed. No Python rule engine was added. No GREEN execution is claimed: exact head still has no reported GitHub status checks and the packaged SBCL/SWI/Nix contract has not been executed in this environment. Storage correction remains authoritative: reusable state defaults to `~/.llm-proxy`, expert state to `~/.llm-proxy/expert`, with explicit config/CLI/Home Manager override. The older XDG-default wording in the issue body is stale; canonical Org/PR design uses the corrected contract. Dotfiles continues to override the consumer corpus to `~/Documents/AI/proxy`.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 20:15:06 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Architecture correction from #20 / research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-011-zero-python-rewrite.org: older text in this issue assigning capture/transport or the local expert envelope to Python is superseded. The accepted implementation is zero Python. Common Lisp owns proxy/capture/configuration/recorder/provider transport plus the existing Tek9/SWI expert-runtime responsibilities; SWI-Prolog remains the sole facts/rules/inference engine; Tek9 remains the canonical durable symbolic KB. Existing Python files/tests/package wiring are migration evidence/debt only and must not be extended. Current RED handoff is research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-012-common-lisp-transport-red.org plus the Common Lisp test system at head 7ce4682e; no HTTP implementation is authorized until that contract is actually executed RED.

Architecture correction from #20 / `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-011-zero-python-rewrite.org`: older text in this issue assigning capture/transport or the local expert envelope to Python is superseded. The accepted implementation is zero Python. Common Lisp owns proxy/capture/configuration/recorder/provider transport plus the existing Tek9/SWI expert-runtime responsibilities; SWI-Prolog remains the sole facts/rules/inference engine; Tek9 remains the canonical durable symbolic KB. Existing Python files/tests/package wiring are migration evidence/debt only and must not be extended. Current RED handoff is `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-012-common-lisp-transport-red.org` plus the Common Lisp test system at head `7ce4682e`; no HTTP implementation is authorized until that contract is actually executed RED.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 21:12:01 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded execution-gate update after the zero-Python reconciliation:

#8 and #10 bodies are now corrected so the canonical backlog no longer assigns transport/capture ownership to Python. #20 + RESEARCH-011/012 remain authoritative.
Active branch/head is still rage/10-expert-runtime-red @ 7ce4682ea16020035588b9b5e280e75cdbe9b98c.
Exact head has no commit statuses and no PR workflow runs; PR #18 has no submitted reviews.
I attempted to make the RED executable in the current runner by provisioning SBCL + SWI-Prolog. The runner has neither sbcl, swipl, nix, nor ros, and its Debian package repositories were unreachable/time-limited, so the toolchain could not be bootstrapped here.
Therefore the CL HTTP lifecycle contract remains defined but not executed. No production HTTP mutation is authorized and no GREEN is claimed.
Tek9 was rechecked: master latest relevant merge remains a9f5b595f5d965163d2b7c518c72a2efd9be13fe (consumable ASDF/Nix package), with no open Tek9 issues or PRs. No Tek9 primitive/change is needed for this slice.

Next executable step remains: run the exact 7ce4682e Common Lisp RED contract in an SBCL-capable environment, record the expected missing START-HTTP-PROXY / STOP-HTTP-PROXY / PROXY-LISTEN-PORT failure, then implement the minimum CL HTTP path.

Bounded execution-gate update after the zero-Python reconciliation: - #8 and #10 bodies are now corrected so the canonical backlog no longer assigns transport/capture ownership to Python. #20 + RESEARCH-011/012 remain authoritative. - Active branch/head is still `rage/10-expert-runtime-red` @ `7ce4682ea16020035588b9b5e280e75cdbe9b98c`. - Exact head has no commit statuses and no PR workflow runs; PR #18 has no submitted reviews. - I attempted to make the RED executable in the current runner by provisioning SBCL + SWI-Prolog. The runner has neither `sbcl`, `swipl`, `nix`, nor `ros`, and its Debian package repositories were unreachable/time-limited, so the toolchain could not be bootstrapped here. - Therefore the CL HTTP lifecycle contract remains **defined but not executed**. No production HTTP mutation is authorized and no GREEN is claimed. - Tek9 was rechecked: `master` latest relevant merge remains `a9f5b595f5d965163d2b7c518c72a2efd9be13fe` (consumable ASDF/Nix package), with no open Tek9 issues or PRs. No Tek9 primitive/change is needed for this slice. Next executable step remains: run the exact `7ce4682e` Common Lisp RED contract in an SBCL-capable environment, record the expected missing `START-HTTP-PROXY` / `STOP-HTTP-PROXY` / `PROXY-LISTEN-PORT` failure, then implement the minimum CL HTTP path.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 22:11:47 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE update: found and fixed a RED-gate wiring defect without touching production HTTP behavior.

canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-013-common-lisp-red-runner.org (cafb39a5)
problem: llm-log-expert-test/Rove existed, but nix flake check never ran it; the only expert-service check still invoked Python unittests, so a Nix-capable machine still could not establish the new Common Lisp transport RED
gate wiring: a2f3f71a adds checks.<system>.common-lisp-transport-contract, invoking asdf:test-system "llm-log-expert-test" under SBCL with Rove and the packaged expert library; no Python runner is involved
the old Python-backed expert-service-contract is now explicitly migration-only evidence and cannot satisfy the zero-Python transport gate
no Common Lisp HTTP production implementation was added

Truthful execution state: this automation container has no sbcl, swipl, nix, or ros, and DNS/package-network access is unavailable. Therefore the new check has not been executed here and no behavioral RED/GREEN claim is made. The accepted RED remains specifically the missing START-HTTP-PROXY, STOP-HTTP-PROXY, and PROXY-LISTEN-PORT assertions, not dependency/harness failure. #12/#13/#15/#17 remain blocked.

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE update: found and fixed a RED-gate wiring defect without touching production HTTP behavior. - canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-013-common-lisp-red-runner.org` (`cafb39a5`) - problem: `llm-log-expert-test`/Rove existed, but `nix flake check` never ran it; the only expert-service check still invoked Python unittests, so a Nix-capable machine still could not establish the new Common Lisp transport RED - gate wiring: `a2f3f71a` adds `checks.<system>.common-lisp-transport-contract`, invoking `asdf:test-system "llm-log-expert-test"` under SBCL with Rove and the packaged expert library; no Python runner is involved - the old Python-backed `expert-service-contract` is now explicitly migration-only evidence and cannot satisfy the zero-Python transport gate - no Common Lisp HTTP production implementation was added Truthful execution state: this automation container has no `sbcl`, `swipl`, `nix`, or `ros`, and DNS/package-network access is unavailable. Therefore the new check has not been executed here and no behavioral RED/GREEN claim is made. The accepted RED remains specifically the missing `START-HTTP-PROXY`, `STOP-HTTP-PROXY`, and `PROXY-LISTEN-PORT` assertions, not dependency/harness failure. #12/#13/#15/#17 remain blocked.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-29 23:19:14 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE update:

Added canonical research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-014-hosted-common-lisp-red-execution.org.
Hosted Nix execution exposed a false-green test harness: Rove returned a failure boolean, but the ASDF test-op discarded it, so failed assertions could still make the Nix derivation succeed.
Fixed failure propagation in expert/llm-log-expert-test.asd at 1f7ebc93eccf6cd5a2923f1dae8490673935a6b7.
Added an expected-RED verifier that accepts only a failing Common Lisp transport contract containing all three missing lifecycle assertions.
Valid behavioral RED is now recorded from run https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33280631648 on immutable head 5e51c3ef87def61c9853935714b73271a9d289de: Nix bootstrap succeeded and the verifier matched missing START-HTTP-PROXY, STOP-HTTP-PROXY, and PROXY-LISTEN-PORT.

This clears the execution-infrastructure blocker but does NOT justify lifecycle stubs. Before production HTTP mutation, extend the CL RED to black-box forwarding fidelity (method/path/query/body/status + duplicate headers), then implement against that stronger contract. No dotfiles or Tek9 mutation in this slice; no merge.

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE update: - Added canonical `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-014-hosted-common-lisp-red-execution.org`. - Hosted Nix execution exposed a false-green test harness: Rove returned a failure boolean, but the ASDF `test-op` discarded it, so failed assertions could still make the Nix derivation succeed. - Fixed failure propagation in `expert/llm-log-expert-test.asd` at `1f7ebc93eccf6cd5a2923f1dae8490673935a6b7`. - Added an expected-RED verifier that accepts only a failing Common Lisp transport contract containing all three missing lifecycle assertions. - Valid behavioral RED is now recorded from run https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33280631648 on immutable head `5e51c3ef87def61c9853935714b73271a9d289de`: Nix bootstrap succeeded and the verifier matched missing `START-HTTP-PROXY`, `STOP-HTTP-PROXY`, and `PROXY-LISTEN-PORT`. This clears the execution-infrastructure blocker but does NOT justify lifecycle stubs. Before production HTTP mutation, extend the CL RED to black-box forwarding fidelity (method/path/query/body/status + duplicate headers), then implement against that stronger contract. No dotfiles or Tek9 mutation in this slice; no merge.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 00:11:53 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE update — stronger ordinary-HTTP RED is now established before production transport mutation.

Canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-015-http-fidelity-black-box-red.org.
Contract commit: 0359d92e4e637d888079ddf55e72d2c9124de81a.
Hosted run: https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33282707089 — completed successfully as an expected-RED verifier.
The Common Lisp/Rove suite now contains a raw loopback HTTP fixture that, once the missing proxy surface exists, asserts provider-prefix routing, exact repeated/encoded query semantics, binary request/response bodies containing NUL, status 418, end-to-end request-header forwarding, and two distinct ordered Set-Cookie response fields.
Current pre-implementation failure is still the declared missing CL surface (MAKE-RUNTIME-CONFIG/upstreams plus proxy lifecycle). The hosted verifier reached the behavioral assertions rather than failing during Nix/SBCL/Rove bootstrap.
No Common Lisp HTTP production implementation was added in this bounded cycle. No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation was needed; dotfiles remains consumer-only with ~/Documents/AI/proxy.

Next authorized slice: implement the minimum real Common Lisp ordinary-HTTP path against this exact contract, then require GREEN before SSE/WebSocket/recorder work.

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE update — stronger ordinary-HTTP RED is now established before production transport mutation. - Canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-015-http-fidelity-black-box-red.org`. - Contract commit: `0359d92e4e637d888079ddf55e72d2c9124de81a`. - Hosted run: https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33282707089 — completed successfully as an expected-RED verifier. - The Common Lisp/Rove suite now contains a raw loopback HTTP fixture that, once the missing proxy surface exists, asserts provider-prefix routing, exact repeated/encoded query semantics, binary request/response bodies containing NUL, status `418`, end-to-end request-header forwarding, and two distinct ordered `Set-Cookie` response fields. - Current pre-implementation failure is still the declared missing CL surface (`MAKE-RUNTIME-CONFIG`/upstreams plus proxy lifecycle). The hosted verifier reached the behavioral assertions rather than failing during Nix/SBCL/Rove bootstrap. - No Common Lisp HTTP production implementation was added in this bounded cycle. No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation was needed; dotfiles remains consumer-only with `~/Documents/AI/proxy`. Next authorized slice: implement the minimum real Common Lisp ordinary-HTTP path against this exact contract, then require GREEN before SSE/WebSocket/recorder work.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 01:14:09 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded Auto-ARADR/Auto-RAGE slice completed for the first Common Lisp ordinary-HTTP transport dependency.

Canonical design first: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-016-http-bootstrap-green.org.

RED baseline independently re-verified from immutable hosted run 33282707089 on 0359d92e4e637d888079ddf55e72d2c9124de81a before implementation.

Implementation added the Common Lisp runtime upstream map plus START-HTTP-PROXY / STOP-HTTP-PROXY / PROXY-LISTEN-PORT and a bounded raw HTTP/1.1 forwarder. The direct Rove/Nix fidelity contract is GREEN on exact current head 0f33782d8d899ef99e64ea7ee9fd02f6a3c22808; hosted run 33285153994 succeeded.

Verified behavior: provider selector removed exactly once; method/path/repeated+encoded query preserved; end-to-end request header preserved; binary request and response bodies with NUL preserved; upstream 418 status preserved; duplicate Set-Cookie fields remain separate.

Implementation evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-002-http-fidelity-green.org.

No Tek9 mutation, no dotfiles mutation, no merge. This does not claim HTTPS, SSE, WebSocket, capture/redaction, provider-family conformance, or final zero-Python completion. Next production mutation needs a new executed RED first.

Bounded Auto-ARADR/Auto-RAGE slice completed for the first Common Lisp ordinary-HTTP transport dependency. Canonical design first: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-016-http-bootstrap-green.org`. RED baseline independently re-verified from immutable hosted run `33282707089` on `0359d92e4e637d888079ddf55e72d2c9124de81a` before implementation. Implementation added the Common Lisp runtime upstream map plus `START-HTTP-PROXY` / `STOP-HTTP-PROXY` / `PROXY-LISTEN-PORT` and a bounded raw HTTP/1.1 forwarder. The direct Rove/Nix fidelity contract is GREEN on exact current head `0f33782d8d899ef99e64ea7ee9fd02f6a3c22808`; hosted run `33285153994` succeeded. Verified behavior: provider selector removed exactly once; method/path/repeated+encoded query preserved; end-to-end request header preserved; binary request and response bodies with NUL preserved; upstream 418 status preserved; duplicate `Set-Cookie` fields remain separate. Implementation evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-002-http-fidelity-green.org`. No Tek9 mutation, no dotfiles mutation, no merge. This does not claim HTTPS, SSE, WebSocket, capture/redaction, provider-family conformance, or final zero-Python completion. Next production mutation needs a new executed RED first.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 02:23:21 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded Auto-ARADR + Auto-RAGE slice completed for finite HTTP immutable capture/redaction.

Canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-017-immutable-http-capture-redaction.org.

RED discipline:

run 33287589143 rejected as invalid product evidence because the new test fixture had a FORMAT arity defect; no production mutation followed it.
corrected exact head 31426657f5bb68871e66a723cde33ce4a845a4bc, run 33287657011: valid RED. Existing HTTP fidelity and credential forwarding remained GREEN; intended capture assertion failed because no event existed (EVENTS = NIL).

Implementation head e3830e76a4713fa331c67e71739453247a9c8a01 adds create-only finite HTTP capture under the configured data directory, exact binary request/response bodies, ordered header evidence, and persistence-only secret redaction while original credentials continue upstream.

GREEN run 33287732659 / job 99193780462 passed the direct Common Lisp/Rove/Nix gate and verified Authorization/X-Api-Key/Cookie forwarding, redacted persisted secrets, duplicate Set-Cookie evidence, visible non-secret headers, exact NUL-containing bodies, and all prior HTTP fidelity assertions.

Execution evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-003-http-capture-red-green.org.

Exact current evidence-only head 1041c2267a8edc9a2a94f86bbdb79a3e289ca629 is GREEN in run 33287815155.

No Tek9 change and no dotfiles change were justified. Next capture production mutation requires an executed concurrency/crash RED before introducing the Sento/cl-gserver single-writer recorder actor. SSE/WebSocket/HTTPS/provider conformance remain out of this bounded GREEN.

Bounded Auto-ARADR + Auto-RAGE slice completed for finite HTTP immutable capture/redaction. Canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-017-immutable-http-capture-redaction.org`. RED discipline: - run `33287589143` rejected as invalid product evidence because the new test fixture had a FORMAT arity defect; no production mutation followed it. - corrected exact head `31426657f5bb68871e66a723cde33ce4a845a4bc`, run `33287657011`: valid RED. Existing HTTP fidelity and credential forwarding remained GREEN; intended capture assertion failed because no event existed (`EVENTS = NIL`). Implementation head `e3830e76a4713fa331c67e71739453247a9c8a01` adds create-only finite HTTP capture under the configured data directory, exact binary request/response bodies, ordered header evidence, and persistence-only secret redaction while original credentials continue upstream. GREEN run `33287732659` / job `99193780462` passed the direct Common Lisp/Rove/Nix gate and verified Authorization/X-Api-Key/Cookie forwarding, redacted persisted secrets, duplicate Set-Cookie evidence, visible non-secret headers, exact NUL-containing bodies, and all prior HTTP fidelity assertions. Execution evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-003-http-capture-red-green.org`. Exact current evidence-only head `1041c2267a8edc9a2a94f86bbdb79a3e289ca629` is GREEN in run `33287815155`. No Tek9 change and no dotfiles change were justified. Next capture production mutation requires an executed concurrency/crash RED before introducing the Sento/cl-gserver single-writer recorder actor. SSE/WebSocket/HTTPS/provider conformance remain out of this bounded GREEN.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 03:15:00 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE recorder update:

Canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-018-single-writer-recorder-crash-contract.org (675615a0).
RED contract: expert/tests/recorder-red.lisp, wired into the authoritative Common Lisp/Rove gate at b0773366f830424ce49ab955ab22860a49803dec.
Hosted run 33289740093, job 99199157484 reached the real CL/Nix contract. All prior HTTP fidelity + immutable capture/redaction assertions stayed GREEN.
Intended RED observed for both recorder concurrency/crash contracts: SIMPLE-ERROR: Missing recorder contract function LLM-LOG-EXPERT::START-RECORDER.
Execution evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-004-recorder-concurrency-crash-red.org (71409178).

The contract now requires one single-writer recorder owner, 12 concurrent producers with exact non-cross-contaminated committed events, and deterministic failure-before-publish semantics where no partial event appears under capture/http/events/ and a later command can succeed without ambiguous replay.

No production recorder mutation followed the RED in this bounded cycle. The selected design is Sento/cl-gserver + staging then atomic same-filesystem publish. Reproducible Sento/cl-gserver Nix/ASDF consumption is not established yet, so do not replace the actor boundary with an ad-hoc mutex just to force GREEN.

No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation was justified. PR #18 remains draft/unmerged.

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/RAGE recorder update: - Canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-018-single-writer-recorder-crash-contract.org` (`675615a0`). - RED contract: `expert/tests/recorder-red.lisp`, wired into the authoritative Common Lisp/Rove gate at `b0773366f830424ce49ab955ab22860a49803dec`. - Hosted run `33289740093`, job `99199157484` reached the real CL/Nix contract. All prior HTTP fidelity + immutable capture/redaction assertions stayed GREEN. - Intended RED observed for both recorder concurrency/crash contracts: `SIMPLE-ERROR: Missing recorder contract function LLM-LOG-EXPERT::START-RECORDER`. - Execution evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-004-recorder-concurrency-crash-red.org` (`71409178`). The contract now requires one single-writer recorder owner, 12 concurrent producers with exact non-cross-contaminated committed events, and deterministic failure-before-publish semantics where no partial event appears under `capture/http/events/` and a later command can succeed without ambiguous replay. No production recorder mutation followed the RED in this bounded cycle. The selected design is Sento/cl-gserver + staging then atomic same-filesystem publish. Reproducible Sento/cl-gserver Nix/ASDF consumption is not established yet, so do not replace the actor boundary with an ad-hoc mutex just to force GREEN. No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation was justified. PR #18 remains draft/unmerged.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 05:13:48 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded Auto-ARADR/RAGE correction: the prior recorder dependency claim from run 33291976121 was not a valid Sento RED. That run failed in the pre-existing Common Lisp transport step and GitHub skipped the later Sento dependency step entirely.

Canonical correction: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-020-recorder-dependency-red-execution.org.

RED-only head: b914ec05fd4e3e8a29133d0984ec58213b10c1a4 on rage/10-expert-runtime-red.

The workflow now reports transport and recorder dependency closure as independent jobs, so nix build -L .#checks.x86_64-linux.common-lisp-recorder-deps executes even if transport is red. Hosted run 33294213110 has reached the Sento dependency command independently. No Sento packaging or recorder production code was added in this slice; no GREEN/RED conclusion is claimed until that job completes with a specific result.

Bounded Auto-ARADR/RAGE correction: the prior recorder dependency claim from run 33291976121 was not a valid Sento RED. That run failed in the pre-existing Common Lisp transport step and GitHub skipped the later Sento dependency step entirely. Canonical correction: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-020-recorder-dependency-red-execution.org`. RED-only head: `b914ec05fd4e3e8a29133d0984ec58213b10c1a4` on `rage/10-expert-runtime-red`. The workflow now reports transport and recorder dependency closure as independent jobs, so `nix build -L .#checks.x86_64-linux.common-lisp-recorder-deps` executes even if transport is red. Hosted run 33294213110 has reached the Sento dependency command independently. No Sento packaging or recorder production code was added in this slice; no GREEN/RED conclusion is claimed until that job completes with a specific result.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 06:21:42 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 dependency-slice update:

Canonical ARADR: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-021-sento-pinned-packaging.org
Executed dependency RED: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-005-sento-dependency-red.org (Component :SENTO not found on exact preimplementation head b914ec05fd4e3e8a29133d0984ec58213b10c1a4, run 33294213110)
Sento 3.4.4 is now pinned to upstream commit 013ab6370042686e65943568b0d97e33319c0f54 with fixed hash sha256-z+AKk8Y09rpF+NgyKhcHNvn0jsjeGe3dSibkv8yySKg= and explicit Nix/SBCL runtime deps.
Exact dependency GREEN: head 00077a450d88c5064e4d588945de2a4dd2bc9c80, run 33296638853, independent common-lisp-recorder-deps job succeeded running the unchanged (asdf:load-system :sento) gate with no ambient Quicklisp.
GREEN evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-006-sento-dependency-green.org.
Existing HTTP/capture contracts remained GREEN in the independent transport job; that job is still intentionally RED only at the recorder behavioral contract because LLM-LOG-EXPERT::START-RECORDER is absent.

No Tek9 mutation and no dotfiles mutation. The Sento packaging blocker is resolved; the next #10 dependency is the already-executed RESEARCH-018 Sento single-writer recorder concurrency/crash RED.

Bounded #10 dependency-slice update: - Canonical ARADR: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-021-sento-pinned-packaging.org` - Executed dependency RED: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-005-sento-dependency-red.org` (`Component :SENTO not found` on exact preimplementation head `b914ec05fd4e3e8a29133d0984ec58213b10c1a4`, run 33294213110) - Sento 3.4.4 is now pinned to upstream commit `013ab6370042686e65943568b0d97e33319c0f54` with fixed hash `sha256-z+AKk8Y09rpF+NgyKhcHNvn0jsjeGe3dSibkv8yySKg=` and explicit Nix/SBCL runtime deps. - Exact dependency GREEN: head `00077a450d88c5064e4d588945de2a4dd2bc9c80`, run 33296638853, independent `common-lisp-recorder-deps` job succeeded running the unchanged `(asdf:load-system :sento)` gate with no ambient Quicklisp. - GREEN evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-006-sento-dependency-green.org`. - Existing HTTP/capture contracts remained GREEN in the independent transport job; that job is still intentionally RED only at the recorder behavioral contract because `LLM-LOG-EXPERT::START-RECORDER` is absent. No Tek9 mutation and no dotfiles mutation. The Sento packaging blocker is resolved; the next #10 dependency is the already-executed RESEARCH-018 Sento single-writer recorder concurrency/crash RED.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 09:25:29 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

#10 bounded RED→GREEN landed on rage/10-expert-runtime-red.

Canonical authority is restored to RESEARCH-004/023: Python owns transparent capture/transport; Common Lisp owns expert runtime + Tek9 + SWI-Prolog supervision; Tek9 is the durable KB; SWI-Prolog owns declared inference.

Executed RED: e763c740a3e3d427758d3dcee6bf2c44ced56ef3, run 33303885632. The isolated Common Lisp/Tek9/SWI gate reached START-EXPERT-HOST and failed on the real product defect in %prolog-worker-path (unbound #:LLM-LOG-EXPERT).

Minimal production fix: 42657f7c6f1073504d9c84d08275957f36e1245e uses the ASDF system name string for the default worker path.

Executed GREEN: exact fix head 42657f7c6f1073504d9c84d08275957f36e1245e, run 33303934852, integration job 99237018845. Proven: Tek9 host open, exact bounded PK retrieval, KB revision binding, declared event_transport SWI inference, nonempty rule version, persistent worker reuse, and rejection of undeclared operations before Prolog invocation.

Evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-007-expert-tek9-prolog-red-green.org.

No Tek9 mutation. No dotfiles mutation. No merge: the independent historical CL transport/recorder job is still red on this recovered branch, so PR #24 remains intentionally draft/non-merge-ready.

#10 bounded RED→GREEN landed on `rage/10-expert-runtime-red`. Canonical authority is restored to RESEARCH-004/023: Python owns transparent capture/transport; Common Lisp owns expert runtime + Tek9 + SWI-Prolog supervision; Tek9 is the durable KB; SWI-Prolog owns declared inference. Executed RED: `e763c740a3e3d427758d3dcee6bf2c44ced56ef3`, run `33303885632`. The isolated Common Lisp/Tek9/SWI gate reached `START-EXPERT-HOST` and failed on the real product defect in `%prolog-worker-path` (unbound `#:LLM-LOG-EXPERT`). Minimal production fix: `42657f7c6f1073504d9c84d08275957f36e1245e` uses the ASDF system name string for the default worker path. Executed GREEN: exact fix head `42657f7c6f1073504d9c84d08275957f36e1245e`, run `33303934852`, integration job `99237018845`. Proven: Tek9 host open, exact bounded PK retrieval, KB revision binding, declared `event_transport` SWI inference, nonempty rule version, persistent worker reuse, and rejection of undeclared operations before Prolog invocation. Evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-007-expert-tek9-prolog-red-green.org`. No Tek9 mutation. No dotfiles mutation. No merge: the independent historical CL transport/recorder job is still red on this recovered branch, so PR #24 remains intentionally draft/non-merge-ready.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 10:17:26 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded Auto-ARADR/RAGE #10 update:

Canonical decision added: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-024-expert-ci-authority-boundary.org.
Current authority is Python capture/transport -> Common Lisp expert service -> Tek9 bounded durable KB -> declared SWI-Prolog inference. The zero-Python/Common-Lisp-transport wording still present in older issue prose is superseded by the current explicit program boundary and RESEARCH-023/024.
Pre-reconciliation run 33304010749 proved the expert integration job GREEN while the overall workflow was RED only on the historical Common-Lisp transport/recorder job.
CI-only commit 32fc13e304179456919c231b0235c9f6ca1bef65 removed that stale transport/Sento acceptance coupling from the active expert branch without modifying production transport, expert code, Tek9, Prolog rules, or dotfiles.
Execution evidence is persisted separately as evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-008-expert-ci-authority-green.org.
Exact current head 7bd8abe66b5708dc6304e4b7c32a2abefb21d641 completed hosted run 33306067089 GREEN on the unchanged common-lisp-expert-integration-contract.
PR #24 is mergeable but remains draft with no submitted reviews/discussions, so it was not merged.
No Tek9 primitive change was required. Dotfiles remains unchanged and continues to pin the stable capture proxy with the consumer data path ~/Documents/AI/proxy.

Next #10 production work remains RED-first: contradictory replay/idempotency execution, derived-assertion provenance/supersession, reasoner failure/recovery, then Python-to-expert fail-open vs explicit require_expert_plane fail-closed integration. #12/#13/#15/#17 remain blocked.

Bounded Auto-ARADR/RAGE #10 update: - Canonical decision added: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-024-expert-ci-authority-boundary.org`. - Current authority is Python capture/transport -> Common Lisp expert service -> Tek9 bounded durable KB -> declared SWI-Prolog inference. The zero-Python/Common-Lisp-transport wording still present in older issue prose is superseded by the current explicit program boundary and RESEARCH-023/024. - Pre-reconciliation run `33304010749` proved the expert integration job GREEN while the overall workflow was RED only on the historical Common-Lisp transport/recorder job. - CI-only commit `32fc13e304179456919c231b0235c9f6ca1bef65` removed that stale transport/Sento acceptance coupling from the active expert branch without modifying production transport, expert code, Tek9, Prolog rules, or dotfiles. - Execution evidence is persisted separately as `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-008-expert-ci-authority-green.org`. - Exact current head `7bd8abe66b5708dc6304e4b7c32a2abefb21d641` completed hosted run `33306067089` GREEN on the unchanged `common-lisp-expert-integration-contract`. - PR #24 is mergeable but remains draft with no submitted reviews/discussions, so it was not merged. - No Tek9 primitive change was required. Dotfiles remains unchanged and continues to pin the stable capture proxy with the consumer data path `~/Documents/AI/proxy`. Next #10 production work remains RED-first: contradictory replay/idempotency execution, derived-assertion provenance/supersession, reasoner failure/recovery, then Python-to-expert fail-open vs explicit `require_expert_plane` fail-closed integration. #12/#13/#15/#17 remain blocked.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 11:19:41 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

#10 bounded Auto-ARADR/Auto-RAGE update — derived assertion provenance/supersession

Canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-025-derived-assertion-provenance-supersession.org.

RED discipline:

3bd9bd1179a04a490af48b75b1c213988f911ef8 / run 33308422242 was a broken test fixture (unmatched parenthesis) and is not counted as RED.
corrected test-only head e4c61b7252fedf8b3dcf2827ccede73007aa7b2e / run 33308526544 is the valid RED: all prior Tek9→SWI assertions passed, then the new contract failed specifically on undefined LLM-LOG-EXPERT::PERSIST-DERIVED-ASSERTION.

GREEN:

implementation b7a9bc74ae7e02b3c9af6e77471e2e85a36e3ad6 / run 33308577798: GREEN.
exported substrate head 983dca3f8741edf9f32913ae93fa22e715f70ed0 / run 33308588756: GREEN.

The unchanged contract now proves bounded source validation, durable source/expert/rule provenance, publication KB revision binding, idempotent identical replay, contradictory stable-ID rejection without overwrite/revision bump, append-only supersession, prior assertion preservation, raw source-event preservation, and rejection of unknown superseded assertions.

Evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-009-derived-assertion-red-green.org.

No Tek9 repo mutation was required; existing fetch*/put*/with-write-transaction APIs were sufficient. No dotfiles or transport mutation.

#10 bounded Auto-ARADR/Auto-RAGE update — derived assertion provenance/supersession Canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-025-derived-assertion-provenance-supersession.org`. RED discipline: - `3bd9bd1179a04a490af48b75b1c213988f911ef8` / run 33308422242 was a broken test fixture (unmatched parenthesis) and is **not** counted as RED. - corrected test-only head `e4c61b7252fedf8b3dcf2827ccede73007aa7b2e` / run 33308526544 is the valid RED: all prior Tek9→SWI assertions passed, then the new contract failed specifically on undefined `LLM-LOG-EXPERT::PERSIST-DERIVED-ASSERTION`. GREEN: - implementation `b7a9bc74ae7e02b3c9af6e77471e2e85a36e3ad6` / run 33308577798: GREEN. - exported substrate head `983dca3f8741edf9f32913ae93fa22e715f70ed0` / run 33308588756: GREEN. The unchanged contract now proves bounded source validation, durable source/expert/rule provenance, publication KB revision binding, idempotent identical replay, contradictory stable-ID rejection without overwrite/revision bump, append-only supersession, prior assertion preservation, raw source-event preservation, and rejection of unknown superseded assertions. Evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-009-derived-assertion-red-green.org`. No Tek9 repo mutation was required; existing `fetch*`/`put*`/`with-write-transaction` APIs were sufficient. No dotfiles or transport mutation.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 12:16:29 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/Auto-RAGE slice: typed reasoner failure + later-request recovery.

Canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-026-reasoner-failure-recovery-contract.org.

Valid RED: exact test-only head cc0df4b213db4acfd97d970c236da2e0edf0200a, run https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33310846343. Existing Tek9→SWI and derived-assertion contracts stayed GREEN; the sole new failure was absence of typed reasoner-failure for malformed/correlation-invalid replies. The recovery half already proved a dead worker session is invalidated and a later independent request starts a fresh SWI session.

Production GREEN: 89173d685bbbb841b6c4848ca7ce63cd3eb168fa, run https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33310965653. Added finite runtime classes :unavailable, :crashed, :timeout, :malformed-reply; stable service protocol codes; malformed JSON/reply/correlation typing; no automatic replay. Full Nix Tek9/SWI integration contract is GREEN.

Evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-010-reasoner-failure-recovery-red-green.org at branch head 12cd503e026089b77781b9dadb1733ea0f7117ba.

Authority note: current explicit program direction/PR #24 remains Python capture+transport, Common Lisp expert runtime, Tek9 durable KB, SWI-Prolog declared inference. The zero-Python text currently present in older #8/#10 issue prose is stale relative to that explicit direction and was not reintroduced.

No Tek9 repo mutation; existing public APIs remain sufficient. No dotfiles mutation; provider census and #12/#13/#15/#17 production work remain untouched.

Bounded #10 Auto-ARADR/Auto-RAGE slice: typed reasoner failure + later-request recovery. Canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-026-reasoner-failure-recovery-contract.org`. Valid RED: exact test-only head `cc0df4b213db4acfd97d970c236da2e0edf0200a`, run https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33310846343. Existing Tek9→SWI and derived-assertion contracts stayed GREEN; the sole new failure was absence of typed `reasoner-failure` for malformed/correlation-invalid replies. The recovery half already proved a dead worker session is invalidated and a later independent request starts a fresh SWI session. Production GREEN: `89173d685bbbb841b6c4848ca7ce63cd3eb168fa`, run https://github.com/lost-rob0t/llm-log/actions/runs/33310965653. Added finite runtime classes `:unavailable`, `:crashed`, `:timeout`, `:malformed-reply`; stable service protocol codes; malformed JSON/reply/correlation typing; no automatic replay. Full Nix Tek9/SWI integration contract is GREEN. Evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-010-reasoner-failure-recovery-red-green.org` at branch head `12cd503e026089b77781b9dadb1733ea0f7117ba`. Authority note: current explicit program direction/PR #24 remains Python capture+transport, Common Lisp expert runtime, Tek9 durable KB, SWI-Prolog declared inference. The zero-Python text currently present in older #8/#10 issue prose is stale relative to that explicit direction and was not reintroduced. No Tek9 repo mutation; existing public APIs remain sufficient. No dotfiles mutation; provider census and #12/#13/#15/#17 production work remain untouched.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 13:21:29 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 cycle update — Python expert availability policy landed RED→GREEN without changing Tek9 or dotfiles.

Canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-027-python-expert-failure-policy.org
Evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-011-python-expert-policy-red-green.org

RED exact head 30b33cf2e1f908fe4dff9960051d1da8bcc48446, run 33313690072: CL/Tek9/SWI stayed GREEN; Python policy job failed specifically because build_app() lacked expert_plane.

Production c1a455bd10804a78ab7294f74cf0a5d4cf65ed03, run 33313845134: both jobs GREEN. Verified with a real aiohttp upstream: unavailable expert fails open by default; explicit require_expert_plane=true returns generic 503 with zero upstream hits; missing expert also fails closed when required; healthy expert forwards; expert exception detail is not reflected.

Current evidence head fbeebff73a9ce659725ccd54aeafdd5a4ef0216f, run 33313909107: both independent jobs GREEN.

No Python rule engine was introduced. Python remains capture/transport; Common Lisp remains expert runtime owner; Tek9 remains durable KB; SWI-Prolog remains inference. Concrete long-lived Python↔Common Lisp adapter and config wiring remain separate next boundaries.

Bounded #10 cycle update — Python expert availability policy landed RED→GREEN without changing Tek9 or dotfiles. Canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-027-python-expert-failure-policy.org` Evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-011-python-expert-policy-red-green.org` RED exact head `30b33cf2e1f908fe4dff9960051d1da8bcc48446`, run 33313690072: CL/Tek9/SWI stayed GREEN; Python policy job failed specifically because `build_app()` lacked `expert_plane`. Production `c1a455bd10804a78ab7294f74cf0a5d4cf65ed03`, run 33313845134: both jobs GREEN. Verified with a real aiohttp upstream: unavailable expert fails open by default; explicit `require_expert_plane=true` returns generic 503 with zero upstream hits; missing expert also fails closed when required; healthy expert forwards; expert exception detail is not reflected. Current evidence head `fbeebff73a9ce659725ccd54aeafdd5a4ef0216f`, run 33313909107: both independent jobs GREEN. No Python rule engine was introduced. Python remains capture/transport; Common Lisp remains expert runtime owner; Tek9 remains durable KB; SWI-Prolog remains inference. Concrete long-lived Python↔Common Lisp adapter and config wiring remain separate next boundaries.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 15:22:25 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 adapter cycle update:

Valid hosted RED: adabdf532edde833a66458739b3a389593ec3c17, run 33316177583. Independent CL/Tek9/SWI contract GREEN and all existing Python expert-policy cases GREEN; the new adapter contract failed specifically because llm_log.expert_adapter.SubprocessExpertPlane did not exist.
Production: e87d51d8dc74cc3106c1b7e33fe5d0a77141fe37 adds one long-lived serialized JSON-lines subprocess adapter with explicit invalidation on timeout/EOF/malformed protocol, no implicit replay, and no raw Prolog-goal API.
Adversarial execution found the initial timeout fixture encoded scheduler/buffering behavior. Those failures are not counted as product evidence. The corrected semantic contract is c5b5eda0a35f859bc089ff785931f697f0cb9ad0.
Exact remote adapter blob 893063bd338af25c6bf9162c4dd93943e73c8b1f and corrected test blob e668c29b1d55610dc5dcfebb630f89403349b0f0 passed 5/5 three consecutive local executions.
Canonical design reconciled in research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-028-python-common-lisp-expert-adapter.org; execution evidence is evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-012-python-common-lisp-adapter-red-green.org.
No hosted current-head GREEN is claimed: API-written post-production commits did not emit a new push workflow run during this cycle.
No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation; ~/Documents/AI/proxy remains unchanged; #12/#13/#15/#17 remain blocked behind #10.

Next RED-first slice: exercise this concrete adapter through real HTTP and dedicated WebSocket fail-open/fail-closed conformance before any PR #5/Home Manager launch wiring.

Bounded #10 adapter cycle update: - Valid hosted RED: `adabdf532edde833a66458739b3a389593ec3c17`, run `33316177583`. Independent CL/Tek9/SWI contract GREEN and all existing Python expert-policy cases GREEN; the new adapter contract failed specifically because `llm_log.expert_adapter.SubprocessExpertPlane` did not exist. - Production: `e87d51d8dc74cc3106c1b7e33fe5d0a77141fe37` adds one long-lived serialized JSON-lines subprocess adapter with explicit invalidation on timeout/EOF/malformed protocol, no implicit replay, and no raw Prolog-goal API. - Adversarial execution found the initial timeout fixture encoded scheduler/buffering behavior. Those failures are not counted as product evidence. The corrected semantic contract is `c5b5eda0a35f859bc089ff785931f697f0cb9ad0`. - Exact remote adapter blob `893063bd338af25c6bf9162c4dd93943e73c8b1f` and corrected test blob `e668c29b1d55610dc5dcfebb630f89403349b0f0` passed 5/5 three consecutive local executions. - Canonical design reconciled in `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-028-python-common-lisp-expert-adapter.org`; execution evidence is `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-012-python-common-lisp-adapter-red-green.org`. - No hosted current-head GREEN is claimed: API-written post-production commits did not emit a new push workflow run during this cycle. - No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation; `~/Documents/AI/proxy` remains unchanged; #12/#13/#15/#17 remain blocked behind #10. Next RED-first slice: exercise this concrete adapter through real HTTP and dedicated WebSocket fail-open/fail-closed conformance before any PR #5/Home Manager launch wiring.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 18:15:31 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 transport-lifecycle slice reached executed RED -> GREEN.

RED: exact test head 15f3056ea6f43138334c198f333febac7a320f78, hosted run 33327310653. Independent CL/Tek9/SWI job stayed GREEN. Existing policy + isolated adapter tests stayed GREEN. New concrete lifecycle contract failed because aiohttp did not start a fresh healthy SubprocessExpertPlane: required HTTP observed running == false, and healthy required WebSocket got 503 before upgrade.

Production: b2139233ee57161d67d17dddd1075b9d3e27ce27 adds only concrete adapter startup/cleanup ownership to llm_log/proxy.py. Startup failure is contained to preserve default fail-open; explicit require_expert_plane remains fail-closed at the existing pre-forward health gate. No Tek9/Prolog semantics or Python rule engine added.

GREEN: hosted run 33327391255; CL/Tek9/SWI job GREEN and Python suite 13/13 GREEN, including healthy required HTTP, healthy required WebSocket relay, WebSocket default fail-open, required fail-closed, adapter no-replay, and no arbitrary Prolog-goal API.

Canonical design updated: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-029-concrete-adapter-transport-lifecycle.org. Separate implementation evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-013-concrete-adapter-transport-lifecycle-red-green.org.

Current branch head after docs: cc0e777c9fd9747da8913999cb974b0b4cb15f63; exact-head workflow 33327491804 is executing. No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation.

Bounded #10 transport-lifecycle slice reached executed RED -> GREEN. RED: exact test head `15f3056ea6f43138334c198f333febac7a320f78`, hosted run `33327310653`. Independent CL/Tek9/SWI job stayed GREEN. Existing policy + isolated adapter tests stayed GREEN. New concrete lifecycle contract failed because aiohttp did not start a fresh healthy `SubprocessExpertPlane`: required HTTP observed `running == false`, and healthy required WebSocket got 503 before upgrade. Production: `b2139233ee57161d67d17dddd1075b9d3e27ce27` adds only concrete adapter startup/cleanup ownership to `llm_log/proxy.py`. Startup failure is contained to preserve default fail-open; explicit `require_expert_plane` remains fail-closed at the existing pre-forward health gate. No Tek9/Prolog semantics or Python rule engine added. GREEN: hosted run `33327391255`; CL/Tek9/SWI job GREEN and Python suite 13/13 GREEN, including healthy required HTTP, healthy required WebSocket relay, WebSocket default fail-open, required fail-closed, adapter no-replay, and no arbitrary Prolog-goal API. Canonical design updated: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-029-concrete-adapter-transport-lifecycle.org`. Separate implementation evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-013-concrete-adapter-transport-lifecycle-red-green.org`. Current branch head after docs: `cc0e777c9fd9747da8913999cb974b0b4cb15f63`; exact-head workflow `33327491804` is executing. No Tek9 or dotfiles mutation.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 20:16:11 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Bounded #10 Home Manager expert-plane slice is now executed RED → GREEN.

Canonical design: research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-031-home-manager-expert-wiring.org
Evidence: evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-015-home-manager-expert-red-green.org

Valid RED: 7230b5cc839e1d3421bf95c232d822670a5c7bd7, run 33332939428. Existing Python expert contracts and CL/Tek9/SWI integration were GREEN; the new HM contract failed specifically because services.llm-log.expert did not exist. An earlier store-path fixture failure is explicitly recorded as invalid evidence, not RED.

Production: b6111a5fbe682bfa70f6922bd2727c380fe46278 adds services.llm-log.expert.{enable,package,dataDir,require} and projects the already-proven CLI launch args into the existing llm-log.service; no second expert daemon, Tek9 mutation, Prolog change, provider change, or Python rule engine.

Exact current documentation/evidence head 870945344c5a2e41a6a5a0f09e50641dc218fd9e is GREEN in run 33333080246 across Home Manager, Python policy/adapter/transport/launch, and Common Lisp/Tek9/SWI jobs.

Dotfiles remains untouched in this slice; ~/Documents/AI/proxy and PR #5 stay isolated. Next consumer integration should be a separately gated transaction.

Bounded #10 Home Manager expert-plane slice is now executed RED → GREEN. Canonical design: `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-031-home-manager-expert-wiring.org` Evidence: `evidence/LLM-LOG-EVIDENCE-015-home-manager-expert-red-green.org` Valid RED: `7230b5cc839e1d3421bf95c232d822670a5c7bd7`, run `33332939428`. Existing Python expert contracts and CL/Tek9/SWI integration were GREEN; the new HM contract failed specifically because `services.llm-log.expert` did not exist. An earlier store-path fixture failure is explicitly recorded as invalid evidence, not RED. Production: `b6111a5fbe682bfa70f6922bd2727c380fe46278` adds `services.llm-log.expert.{enable,package,dataDir,require}` and projects the already-proven CLI launch args into the existing `llm-log.service`; no second expert daemon, Tek9 mutation, Prolog change, provider change, or Python rule engine. Exact current documentation/evidence head `870945344c5a2e41a6a5a0f09e50641dc218fd9e` is GREEN in run `33333080246` across Home Manager, Python policy/adapter/transport/launch, and Common Lisp/Tek9/SWI jobs. Dotfiles remains untouched in this slice; `~/Documents/AI/proxy` and PR #5 stay isolated. Next consumer integration should be a separately gated transaction.

lost-rob0t commented

2026-08-30 22:15:14 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Current authority correction: sections of this issue that say #20 removes Python are superseded. Canonical reconciliation is research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-033-expert-authority-regression-reconciliation.org (commit 07b92274d4312cbfe228be56524b430348687d22). #10 continues with Python as capture/transport only; Common Lisp owns Tek9 access, typed objects, bounded fact materialization, SWI-Prolog supervision/result validation and durable derived assertions. Existing PR #24 remains the active substrate branch. Do not implement a Python rule engine or a Common Lisp transport rewrite.

Current authority correction: sections of this issue that say #20 removes Python are superseded. Canonical reconciliation is `research/LLM-LOG-RESEARCH-033-expert-authority-regression-reconciliation.org` (commit `07b92274d4312cbfe228be56524b430348687d22`). #10 continues with Python as capture/transport only; Common Lisp owns Tek9 access, typed objects, bounded fact materialization, SWI-Prolog supervision/result validation and durable derived assertions. Existing PR #24 remains the active substrate branch. Do not implement a Python rule engine or a Common Lisp transport rewrite.